Been reading A LOT of Christian perspectives on gender roles lately and my brain sorta aches from the weighty and emotional back-and-forth of it all.
One interesting argument put forth by the complementarian/patriarchal side (I'm so so so sorry, I've read so many articles in the last 12 hours and I can't find which one it was. Terrible of me I know.) is the 'you shall desire your husband and he shall rule over you' curse, as an excuse for imbalance of power in male-female relationships. Um, yeah.
This could all just be me misreading and misunderstanding the Bible, so please feel free to discuss, but when I think of Biblical curses, I don't think of them as being the same as Biblical commands. When God curses Cain, the first murderer ever, Cain cries out that the punishment is too harsh and he fears that other people will see his cursedness and use it as an excuse to carry out their own vengeance and kill him. God tells him that anyone who does so will incur a punishment seven times more severe! So is a curse something that people need to rush out and fulfill on behalf of the cursed person? I've never thought so.
When God curses Adam and Eve He doesn't go to Adam and say, "Look, you're wife's going to desire you: rule over her." He says it to Eve, giving her a concrete consequence of her behaviour. He gives Adam a concrete consequence for Adam's behaviour too: life's going to be hard and short and work will be difficult and painful. If we are meant to enforce the opression of women, does this mean that we should tear down any man who finds himself in a fulfilling and enjoyable job?
It's an imperfect metaphor but I always saw God as the doctor going, "You jumped off the cliff at this angle: these are the bones you broke." The curse is not a part of God's original plan for the Earth, but a symbol of the Earth's brokeness! The curse is not a command on which to base behaviour but a sign that tells how commands have been broken and behaviour is not as it should be!
When humanity rebelled against God's command, it's as if the perfectly running train was driven off its tracks by a rebellious driver. Now the train is broken - but we should still try to drive the train on the tracks as was originally intended, right? Even if the train is broken and halting?
I am not a feminist; at least, I don't agree with all the agendas of second- and third-wave feminism. I tend to be very THAT BATHWATER STILL HAS A BABY IN IT about nearly everything, so I find it very difficult to definitely pick a side on political and social issues. I place a lot of value on traditionally 'feminine' qualities, many of which cop a lot of ridicule and abuse these days... such as a propensity to prioritise family life, community and children over breadwinning... or simply virtues that are seen as 'feminine', such as patience, meekness, gentleness and compassion. Let me make myself clear: I don't see these characteristics as particularly gendered at all - I value these qualities wherever I find them in humanity, whether it be male or female. Feminism and I can't agree a lot of the time because it seems to me that feminists reject these values and ideas in favour of qualities more traditionally 'masculine', such as leadership, independence, fighting spirit and courage. Which are all fantastic, wonderful qualities... just not necessarily better than those qualities traditionally seen as 'feminine'.
“I am looking for someone to share in an adventure that I am arranging, and it’s very difficult to find anyone.”
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Labels
A. A. Milne
abortion
About A Boy
action movies
ads
Agatha Christie
Alice In Wonderland
Andrew Garfield
Anglophilia
angst
Aqualung
Atonement
audible goodness
Audrey Hepburn
Babies
baby
Basil The Great Mouse Detective
BBC
Bear Grylls
Beatrix Potter
Beauty and the Beast
Bedtime stories
Benedict Cumberbatch
Bible verses of awesome
Billabong
Billy Joel
Black Books
Blackstump
books
books you are unlikely to have read
boys
Britan
Britishness
Brooke Fraser
Butlers and Valets - I want one
C. S. Lewis
Cabin Pressure
Cat
Cellos
Chameleon Circuit
chick flicks
childhood
children's books
children's television shows
Chocolat
Chocolate
Christmas
clothes
coffee
Coldplay
culture
cute asian couples
David Tennant
Dev Patel
Dick Van Dyke
Disney films
Doctor Horrible
Doctor Who
dreams
Easter
Easter Show
Emma
Enid Blyton
Excerpts
excitement
family
fanvids
Fear
Feminism
film
firefighters
Firefly
food
Freckles
freedom
friends
fun links
G. K. Chesterton
Gerald Durrell
Gilbert and Sullivan
God
good things
Gregory Peck
hair
Headache
History
home
Homeschool
hopes
hot chocolate
Howl's Moving Castle
Hugarian Rhapsody
hugs
humiliation
I love you
impudence
information
Jane Austen
Jane Austen mini-series
Japanese stuff
Jeeves and Wooster
Josh Groban
Karen and the Babes
kiddiwinks
Knitting
L. M. Montgomery
Lady Gaga
Landon Pigg - what a funny name
language
Laughter
laziness
Legolas
Les Miserable
life
lists
literature
Lord Of The Rings
love
loveliness
lovely music
Lovely Voices
Manliness
Martin Freeman
Mary Poppins
Matt Smith
me
Meet the Robinsons
Michael Bublé
Michael Crawford
Miranda
misogyny
movies
Mumford and Sons
Music
musicals
Nanowrimo
Narnia
nasty awful films
nostalgia
Old fashioned
old movies
opinions
Orthodoxy
Oscar Wilde
pain
penguins
Phantom of the Opera
pictures
Poetry
Pride and Prejudice actors who are awesome
princesses
procrastination
productivity
QI
Queen Victoria
quotes
rain
rants
Regina Spektor
reviews
Rhett and Link
Roman Holiday
romance
Romola Garai
Rowan Atkinson
S
screen caps
Secondhand Lions
Sesame Street
Sherlock
Sherlock Holmes
silliness
Simon and Garfunkel
soundtracks
Stephen Fry
Stephen Moffat...
stuff I like
stupidity
suits
tea
television - that dreaded monster
Ten Tenors
Terry Pratchett
the 90s
The Help
The Hobbit
The Princess Bride
The Whitlams
the zoo
theatre
things that make me sad
things to blog about later
thoughtlessness
three fingers
tiredness
treating fictional characters like real people
U2
uni
Vampires
videos
weddings
Why does this post have so many views?
Wind in the Willows
Winnie the Pooh
Wodehouse
words
writers
writing
you and your sneaky literary references...
YouTube
Well done friend <3
ReplyDeleteThank you! I get terribly nervous about putting opinions out there, but it's really cool to discuss this stuff :-)
Delete